CONTENT OF THIS PAGE IS UNDER REVIEW
This page represents a comparison between Legacy Stack (aka "4.x" stack) vs Platform Stack (previously referred to as "Symfony" or "6.x" stack); it will be updated as new stack matures. Note: Features mentioned on the black list are still available in 5.x, but via legacy kernel so you will need to use "pure legacy" or a mixed setup using "legacy fallbacks".
For a list of Symfony features supported out of the box, see here.
For additional related topics see Legacy code and features and Intro for eZ Publish 4.x/3.x developers.
Known existing integration (white list):
| 5.x Feature | 4.x Feature | Note/Limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Content Model | 5.x aimed at not adding any features in the content/data model that would lead to backwards compatibility breaks, new features will instead be introduced when we reach "eZ Platform 1.0" and beyond. | |
| Content* | (Content) Object |
|
| (Content) Relation | (Object) Relation | |
| Field | (Object) Attribute | Missing FieldTypes will cause eZ Publish to return exception, this can be avoided by implementing<TODO:Add link when article on this> the FieldType or configuring it as "NullType" |
| FieldType | DataType | See FieldTypes reference for list of supported types, known unsupported FieldTypes are mentioned in Known issues |
| Locations | Node |
|
| Section |
| |
| ContentType | (Content) Class | |
| FieldDefinition | (Content) Class Attribute | |
| FieldGroups | (Content) Class Attribute Grouping | |
| ObjectState | ObjectState | |
| UrlAlias | ||
| UrlWildcard | ||
| Language | ||
| User | ||
| UserGroup | Can by design (and intention) only have one location in 5.x when using Public API UserService | |
| Policy | ||
| PolicyLimitation | ||
| Role | ||
| RoleLimitation | ||
| RoleAssignment | Currently not possible to delete specific assignment by id, can be deleted by Role and User. | |
| Core | ||
| Public API | n/a | Legacy/4.x does not have a official public API, almost all internal functions are exposes publicly |
| REST API | 5.1 and higher includes a working read/write REST v2 API, 4.x had a readonly REST v1 API as of 4.5 | |
| Development environment | Development mode | In 5.x this is provided by Symfony, and web debugger is extended by eZ Publish. |
| Web stack | 5.x web stack is Symfony with several eZ features on top | |
| Controllers | Modules | |
| Bundles | Extensions | |
| (Twig) Template system | (eZ) Template system | |
| ViewProvider | Override system | Restricted to viewLocation in 5.0, viewContent added in 5.1, for changing presentation logic. |
| Controller override | n/a | 5.2 added feature for being able to also use override system of View Provider to also be able to override content controller under your own conditions to be able to modify behavior. |
| Theme system | Design system | Planned to use LiipThemeBundle, however as there is lack of caching and support for assets currently which is blocking us from using it easily. |
| HTTP Cache | View- / Static- Cache | For anonymous users with content aware caching since 5.0, also for logged in users with context aware caching since 5.2 |
| SiteAccess | Site access | Custom Url, host, port and combination matching to a specific set of settings |
| SiteAccessGroup | n/a | New in 5.x, grouping of related SiteAccesses and common settings for them, typically used to denote a "Site" |
| CSRF | eZ FormToken | Provided by Symfony |
| Render + Query / API use | fetch functions | Combining the render functionality of Symfony with Override system and API you are able to create reusable views of your content similarly to how you would use fetch functions in the past, but getting cache and view / logic separation handled in a native way. |
| Data | ||
| Persistence cache | Cluster- / Class- / ClassAttribute- / var- / "Global"- cache | Introduced in 5.1, multi repository (aka multi-db) setups support added in 5.2. |
| IO | Cluster (-ing of files) | Currently uses 4.x cluster system, new and simpler file clustering is planned for "eZ Platform 1.0" however this is abstracted away by the API and will only affect how cluster setups are configured. |
| Multi repository | Multi-db | Supported, however see note on "Persistence cache", as of 5.3 with own "repository" configuration. |
\* When referring a specific instance of any of the content model entries, either "object" or "item" is normal to append depending on context. In our BDD specifications the domain names have "object" appended to them forming "Content object(s)", "Location object(s)" and so on.
Known missing in Symfony stack (black/grey list):
Note: Missing integration doesn't mean the system can not use the feature in a new installation relying on the new stack, but if it needs, it shall rely on a fallback to the legacy stack. For instance: a website with a shop system could be done in twig and rely on legacy only for the fallback for shop parts.
| Feature | Note/Limitation |
|---|---|
| Core | |
| Rating | User Rating not currently supported by API (the service to deal with ratings, rating field type already exists), planned to be implemented later when some convention for FieldType provided API's are established. |
| Shop | No shop or field(/data) types related to shop currently supported by API, see Known issues. This is planned for "eZ Platform 1.x" or a release shortly thereafter, it will most likely use parts of Sylus for this functionality. |
| eZComment | ezcomments was replaced in 5.2 with a CommentsBundle that will provide an agnostic system to integrate 3rd party comment services. Out of the box supporting Disqus and Facebook integration but can via custom integration also work with other 3rd party systems (example: service, content model based comments or even ezcomments) |
| Content Editing | Content editing module is not implemented yet, but custom needs can for instance be solved with Public API+Symfony controllers or use of javascript REST client + REST API. |
| Module Permissions | Controller / Bundle Permissions is not fully integrated with eZ Publish Repository permission system yet, currently standard Symfony firewall rules need to be used. Public API however has full support for permissions and limitations, and is as of 5.2 known to support legacy most edge cases. |
| UrlAlias Routing | UrlAlias has the same model as before and hence does not support routing directly to a bundle:controller:action |
| Workflow | Planned for future version, see Shop. Simple workflows already possible by using Symfony evens and Public API "Signals". |
| Information Collector | Planned as a Form builder UI basically using Symfony Forms + swiftmailer for mail transport, might reuse content types similarly to how Information Collector did it. |
| Package system | Planned to return as a import/export system which uses either API or SPI directly to replicate some or full amount of content from one repository to another, preferred format: XML using XML reader/writer. |
| Menu management | Menu system in Platform will use KnpMenu bundle, a light version is scheduled for 5.3 while a more deep integration is planned for 5.4. |
| PDF Export | Not currently planned, could be re-implemented outside of Core |
| RSS feeds | Currently no API for managing RSS feeds, REST view can be used as basis of feeds. |
| Frontend Editing | See "Content Editing". Be aware that eZ Flow timeline feature is not available in the legacy admin (only in front end editing), hence not usable on the new stack. |
| Preview | Comes with 5.3, versions before that uses legacy for preview. |
| Search | Search API exists, but front end is currently using legacy fallback (ezfind & ezsearch) and 5.x Search API uses SQL for now while Solr implementation will be added in 2014. |
| User module | User login, login handlers and SSO handlers uses Symfony authentication system as of 5.3, change-password, forgot-password, register, profile and editing currently uses legacy fallback. |
| oAuth 2.0 | oAuth 1.0 supported in REST v1 in legacy, planned for new stack and REST v2 for future 5.x version. |
| Fetch alias | Planned for future version as a way to specify a query with support for dynamic variables given to it. Currently also possible by means of OOP extending existing query functionality. |
| Extensions | (aka Bundles) |
| eZ Tags | Planned for future 5.x version, still community supported in legacy stack on 5.x. |
| eZ SI | eZ SI is purely legacy, not required in Symfony as it support ESI natively. ez SI is still supported in legacy stack on 5.x. |
| eZ Content staging | No equivalent yet on the new stack, still supported in legacy stack on 5.x. |
| eZ Style editor | No equivalent on the new stack, still supported in legacy stack on 5.x up until 5.1. |
| eZ Survey | No equivalent yet on the new stack, still supported in legacy stack on 5.x. |
| * | For other extensions still supported on legacy, see http://doc.ez.no/List-of-eZ-Publish-extensions-and-their-support-options |
For additional comparison between 4.x/legacy stack vs 5.x stack, see the following community provided spreadsheet provided "as is" with no guarantee on accuracy of content: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AgGKn8SQ_akMdFQ3VU0wMlR3cENxTDZ2dkhUcVN2SWc#gid=0